Stepbrother (Codey Steele) is in bed, looking at a photo on his laptop of his sister Julia (Alex Coal) and her friend Kate (Whitney Wright) wearing bikinis. With his fingers he crops the photo to just display Kate, and he starts masturbating.
Julia appears at his doorway and sees him wanking off to Kate’s image. Returning to her own bedroom, Julia thinks (voice-over): “What does she have that I don’t?”, as she gazes at the same photo on her laptop. Speaking aloud, she says: “Fuck them both!”.
Next morning in the kitchen, Julia chides her sibling about his lack of sleep the night before. “I saw you jerking off to my best friend”, she says. “Why her?”. Impulsively she kisses him on the lips, and he pulls away from her.
“Don’t you think I’m attractive?” He responds: “Okay, you’re very pretty. You’re not my type.” Later, Julia is alone on her bed pondering her situation. She phones Kate, hoping to exchange some old clothes with her. Kate comes over and they check out the duds, Julia choosing a two-piece orange outfit of Kate’s to try on. “How do I look?”, she asks her friend. “Like me”, Kate responds. “Did you ever want to look like me?”, Julia asks.”Sometimes, yeah”, says Kate. Stepbrother enters the bedroom, and Julia asks him “How do I look?”. “Yeah, it looks nice”. Julia says: “It was Kate’s in school”. Turning to Kate, Julia asks: “You remember my brother, right?”. Kate answers: “Yeah, I think we met at your parents’ wedding”. “Yeah, you looked great”, he responds to Kate.
“You know I was voted the prettiest girl in the class”, Julia interjects. “You were always the pretty one”, Kate concedes. “I think you look really pretty Kate”, says stepbrother. At this point Julia sends her brother away. Alone again with Kate, she avers “He’s so weird. I don’t like the way he looks at you -it’s creepy”. “I have an idea, you know what would be super fun? What if you made me up to look just like you?”, Julia asks. “I’m already wearing your outfit, right? And we do look alike?”. They pose together in the mirror, and Kate agrees.
Stepbrother is lying on his bed typing on his phone, when Julia walks in, seen in the dim light by the doorway. “Kate?”, he inquires. She moves closer into the light and says “Isn’t this what you wanted?”. “Julia, I don’t understand”, he says. :Call me Kate”, she murmurs. He repeats: “I don’t know what’s going on”. “Kate gave me a little bit of a makeover”, Julia explains, adding: “Do you like it?”. “You look just like her”, he says.
Julia crawls across the bed and gives him a big kiss. “Am I your type now?”. They kiss again, but he says: “I don’t think we should be doing this”. “Just pretend I’m her”, says Julia and kisses him again. He backs off a bit, saying: “I don’t know -it’s too weird”. She kisses him again and his defenses evaporate.